First-Time Horse Owner Starter Guide: What to Do Before You Buy
Before you shop horses, lock down where the horse will live and what that place actually includes in writing. Ask the barn manager exactly how many times hay is fed, whether grain is included, who changes blankets, who holds for vet and farrier, and what happens if you’re out of town for a week. A “cheap” board bill can turn expensive fast when every service is an add-on, and first-time owners get caught here all the time. If turnout is limited or group turnout is chaotic, your horse’s behavior under saddle will reflect that, no matter how good the horse looked on the sales video.
Build your monthly budget from real local numbers, not internet averages. Call two farriers, two vets, and at least one emergency clinic and write down current rates for trims, shoeing, vaccines, fecal testing, dental float, farm-call fees, and after-hours emergencies. Then add tack replacement, supplements, fly control, deworming strategy, and trailer or shipping costs. A practical starting point is to keep a separate emergency fund you can access same day, because colic and lacerations do not wait for payday and payment plans are not guaranteed.
Decide how you will get skilled eyes on your side before you test ride anything. If you don’t yet have a trainer, pay one to consult for the buying process instead of trying to “figure it out as you go.” Your trainer should review sale videos, attend trials, and tell you no when your nerves and excitement push you toward the wrong horse. If you can’t get a trainer, at minimum bring an experienced rider who has no financial connection to the seller and will speak honestly in front of you.
Write your non-negotiables and stick to them. For a first horse, that usually means age range with enough mileage, consistent soundness history, suitable height and build for your confidence, and documented behavior on trails, in traffic, or at shows depending on your goals. “Needs confident rider” is usually code for behavior that will overwhelm a beginner under stress. A kind eye and cute color do not matter if the horse bolts in open space, cannot stand tied, or has never loaded quietly in a trailer.
When you go to try a horse, watch from the ground before you get on. Ask to see the horse caught from the field, groomed, tacked, mounted, ridden first by the current rider, and then ridden by you. If the horse is already sweaty when you arrive, ask why. If the seller won’t let you see loading, standing for the farrier position, or basic handling with ears and feet, treat that as useful information and walk away. You are not buying a ten-minute ride; you are buying every ordinary day around that ride.
Always do a pre-purchase exam with an independent vet you choose, not the seller’s regular vet. Tell your vet exactly what job you need this horse to do and your risk tolerance, because findings are only meaningful in context. A mild issue may be acceptable for light trail work and unacceptable for jumping goals. Include baseline bloodwork and discuss radiographs based on age, use, and exam findings. If anything feels rushed, pause; pressure is a sales tactic, and good horses still exist tomorrow.
Get the terms in writing before money changes hands. The bill of sale should clearly state horse identity, purchase price, date, any included tack, trial terms if applicable, and who is responsible for care and injury risk during trial. Clarify whether deposits are refundable and under what conditions. Keep copies of Coggins, registration papers, vaccine records, deworming history, and current feed program. Verbal promises disappear the minute there is a disagreement.
Prepare your first 30 days before the horse arrives. Schedule the farrier and your first routine vet visit, set up feed transitions slowly over 7 to 14 days, and keep the horse’s initial routine simple and consistent. Limit new stressors, avoid introducing five new supplements at once, and keep riding expectations low while the horse settles. Most early blowups come from changing everything on day one and then reading the horse’s stress as “bad behavior.”
Plan your support team like you plan your tack room. You need a trainer or experienced mentor, a reliable farrier, a primary vet, and one backup transport option for emergencies. Put all numbers in your phone and on a printed card at the barn. Decide now who can help if you are sick, traveling, or injured. First-time owners do best when they assume they will need help and set that help up in advance, not after a crisis starts.
If you feel yourself getting attached to a horse that doesn’t meet your safety criteria, step back for 24 hours and review your non-negotiables and budget line by line. The right first horse should make ordinary days easier, not harder. You want a horse that forgives beginner timing, handles routine care without drama, and gives you room to learn. Buying boring and reliable is not settling; it is how you stay safe, keep your confidence, and still enjoy horses a year from now.
If you want a next step after this, read Pasture Safety Checklist: Fencing, Toxic Plants, and Water Risk and How to Read a Horse’s Body Condition Score (BCS) at Home.
Continue reading
Pasture Safety Checklist: Fencing, Toxic Plants, and Water Risk • How to Read a Horse’s Body Condition Score (BCS) at Home • Horse Deworming Basics: Fecal Testing, Timing, and Common Mistakes